Review: Warm Bodies by Isaac Marion

9475392

Rating: ★ ★ ½ ☆ ☆
Date read: October 10 to 14, 2013
Read count: 1

Not nearly as dead as it could have been, for a zombie tale, that is. If it had been more dead, it could have been a zombie tale I’d enjoy.

As it is though, it’s a hormonal combination of teenage angst and existential crises, typical of what you’d find in a Shakespearean remake with the purpose of appealing to the current generation of YA readers. This relatively new dead spin on the Romeo and Juliet story doesn’t appeal to me personally, just as most revamps of Shakespearean “love stories” don’t appeal to me. What it comes down to is a matter of taste, really, and also because I don’t care for Shakespeare very much.

Overall though, the writing was a pleasant surprise, and many of the prosey descriptive passages depicting barren settings, like abandoned lots and other wastelands, were some of my favorite moments. YA authors are not known for their writing merits or prowess, and so I had been expecting this book to be similar to its weak-in-prose and high-in-angst forerunners. It surprised me though by being more intellectual than your average bear genre YA and more “humane,” for lack of a better word, than average zombie or monster fiction. (Despite the somewhat eye-rolling love story at the heart of it.)

The story is OK overall, but if you’re fed up with Romeo and Juliet remakes or you’re overwhelmed by the amount of zombies in the market, then you’d probably not like this book. But if you’re looking for quick and light post-apocalyptic adventure, you might want to consider it.

As decent as the story is, the characterization is very flat and typical of what you’d find in genre fiction, though not typical of what you might expect in a supposedly character-driven story. Many reviewers say the weakest point of the book is dialogue, and I agree. Too much angst and brooding, not enough getting to the point. I think the book would have been a lot better if most of the conversations between R and Julie were cut out, to be replaced with plot development. And maybe if the “love story” angle was cut out too, to be replaced with…nothing. But that’s just a matter of personal reading preference.

My biggest issue with this book is internal monologue, which seems contradictory to say since I just said I liked the writing. The thing is there are just too many internal monologues running too close together that did little to build up this dark and grim near-future post-apocalyptic world. And while I liked the airport setting, it wasn’t featured enough in between R’s long-winded internal monologues and Julie’s brooding. There’s also not enough story progression for my liking. The plot stays very much flat even as certain events are pushing the story forward, which threw the story off-balance.

And another thing, I don’t like first person POV. When the narration is literally made up of internal monologues strung together, the character spewing these words has to be really, really, extremely interesting for the story to work. Otherwise, it’s just boring.

That’s not to say this book was a terrible read. It wasn’t terrible–more contradiction? It’s just unfortunate enough to have all the things I don’t care for, all pushed into one book.

Whenever I come across a book such as this, I’m always glad I’m no longer a teenager. This book is the embodiment of almost everything I don’t like and don’t like to remember about adolescence. If it weren’t for the zombie aspects and/or post-apocalyptic setting (both flooding the market right now), this story would not stand out in the sea of generic genre fiction. It certainly would not have made an impact (or been turned into a movie) if it was adult genre fiction.

* * * * *

Maybe if I’d read this book before Raising Stony Mayhall, I would have been able to appreciate it more and find the existential concepts it introduced nuanced and interesting. Daryl Gregory is a tough act to follow. I think he ruined the whole zombie genre for me by having written such a great book and a great zombie character.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Review: Warm Bodies by Isaac Marion

  1. Sophie October 15, 2013 / 5:34 pm

    I’ve never read Warm Bodies, but I remember when the movie came out earlier this year and some of my friends told me that the book was better than the movie… which apparently doesn’t translate to “this book was amazing!” like I previously thought, haha. Since you liked Raising Stony Mayhall more, I’ll probably end up reading that before I read Warm Bodies. Thanks for the review!

    Like

    • Mimi October 15, 2013 / 8:24 pm

      Not a problem. Thanks for stopping by and reading. 🙂

      If you still plan on reading both Warm Bodies and Raising Stony Mayhall, then it would be better to start with Warm Bodies, since it’s the weaker of the two, so you can appreciate Daryl Gregory’s subtlety when you get to Stony. If I could go back and read both again, this is the order in which I’d read them.

      Like

      • Sophie October 15, 2013 / 8:38 pm

        Oh, that’s a good point! But I’d rather read as many great books as I can and save the OK books for when I run out of things I really want to read. Raising Stony Mayhall is going on my TBR list, but I probably won’t be reading Warm Bodies unless I’m really desperate. I prefer the instant gratification of an amazing book now rather than building up to it. 🙂

        Like

        • Mimi October 16, 2013 / 6:35 pm

          I understand completely. There’s barely enough time to read the books we look forward to reading, let alone time left over for books that only seem marginally interesting.

          Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s